| CableACE Awards (ACE Awards up to 13th) | ||||||||
| Year | Annual | Nominations | Nominations Announced | Awards Telecast | Host | Winner | Aired | Comments |
| 1991 | 13th | Best Comedy Series | 11/21/1991 | 1/12/1992 | Danny Glover | Dream On | TNT | BBI staff attended |
| Cybill Shepherd | ||||||||
| 1992 | 14th | Writing for a Comedy Series | 11/17/1992 | 1/17/1993 | Lily Tomlin | Dream On | Lifetime | BBI staff attended |
| 1993 | 15th | Art Direction in a Comedy Series | Sinbad | Mastergate | TNT | Joel attended | ||
| Best Comedy Series | 11/2/1993 | 1/16/1994 | Mariel Hemingway | Larry Sanders Show | ||||
| Writing for a Comedy Series | Beau Bridges | Larry Sanders Show | ||||||
| 1994 | 16th | Best Comedy Series | 11/2/1994 | 1/15/1995 | Bill Maher | Larry Sanders Show | TNT | Attendees not known |
| 1995 | 17th | Writing an Entertainment Special - The MST3K Little Gold Statue Preview Special |
9/20/1995 | 12/2/1995 | Mary Tyler Moore | Dennis Miller Live: America: Where Did Our Sense of Humor Go? |
TNT | Attendees not known |
| 1996 | 18th | Best Comedy Series | 9/11/1996 | 11/16/1996 | Drew Carey | Larry Sanders Show | TNT | Attendees not known |
| 1997 | 19th | Best Comedy Series | 9/23/1997 | 11/15/1997 | David Hyde-Pierce | Larry Sanders Show | TNT | Last CableACE. |
| Sela Ward | Not attended by BBI. | |||||||
| NOTE: This is MST3K was nominated for Best Comedy Special for the 1993 awards, but for Comedy Central, not the writers from Best Brains. | ||||||||
| The show lost to John Leguizamo's Spic-O-Rama (HBO). | ||||||||
| Peabody Award | ||||||||
| 1993 | 53rd | Excellence in television broadcasting for using superb, clever writing with wonderfully terrible B-grade movies. | 3/31/1994 | 5/17/1994 | Ed
Bradley. Held at Waldorf-Astoria in New York City |
|||
| Emmy Awards | ||||||||
| 1994 | 46th | Outstanding Achievement in Writing in a Variety or Music Program | 7/21/1994 | 9/11/1994 | Ellen DeGeneres Patricia Richardson | Dennis Miller Live | ABC | Writers attended, but not sure exactly which ones. |
| 1995 | 47th | Outstanding Achievement in Writing in a Variety or Music Program | 7/20/1995 | 9/10/1995 | Jason Alexander Cybill Shepherd | Dennis Miller Live | FOX | Mike, Trace, Paul, Frank, Mike Dodge, Bridget, Kevin, Mary Jo, Jim, Colleen Williams |
| Saturn Awards | ||||||||
| 2004 | 30th | Best DVD
Collection - DVD Sets 2-4 |
2/11/2004 | 5/5/2004 | Jeffery Ross | The Adventures of Indiana Jones | ||
| 2006 | 32nd | Best DVD Collection - DVD Sets 7-8 |
2/15/2006 | 5/2/2006 | Jeffery Ross | Bela Lugosi Collection | ||
| 2007 | 33rd | Best DVD Television Release - DVD Sets 9-10 |
2/20/2007 | 5/10/2007 | Greg Grunberg Jeffery Ross |
Masters of Horror | ||
| NOTE: 2004 awards are for the eligibility year 2003. | ||||||||